Analogy
Having an opinion is like the difference between mastery of a martial art and buying a gun.
In martial arts, it takes time and effort to develop mastery, and the byproduct is an enhanced appreciation and respect for the power which you now wield. You know that using force is a last resort because you are aware of the serious and irreversible damage you can do. Conversely, people who buy guns may not understand or respect the devastating effects they can now impart.
Having an opinion is the same because we should take the time and make the effort to have a well-informed opinion. However, this, like martial arts, is difficult and often uncomfortable, leading most people to bypass this crucial step. They get the clickbait headline, the “tldr,” and think they now understand the situation. Interestingly, and this should now serve as a red flag, those who are most vocal and emotional about topics typically lack deep fluency. Often, when someone is fanatical about something, it is because it is in doubt. Nobody goes on about the sun rising.
Do not hold your views too firmly. Every fool is fully convinced, and everyone fully persuaded is a fool: the more erroneous his judgment the more firmly he holds it.
Diagram
Example
Charles Darwin contemplated his theory of natural selection for more than 20 years before he finally published his world-changing manifesto, The Origin of Species.
Why did he wait so long and risk being beaten to the punch? One, he was aware of the implications – religious and otherwise – that his theory surfaced. He wanted to make sure that he understood and could argue for the opposition better than they could.
He didn’t sweep these under the rug like many might, but brought them to the forefront, exposing them to the light of day. He addressed people’s best objections clearly and upfront, arguing their side better than they ever could, and then going on to disprove them anyway. Darwin saw what people might say, turned it into what they ought to say, and then answered.
Importantly, you should also list any points of agreement (especially if they are not matters of general or widespread agreement) and mention anything you have learned from the other side. Only then are you permitted to say so much as a word of rebuttal or criticism. Besides enabling you to better understand the opposition, there is another welcome effect in that your targets will be a receptive audience for your criticism: you have already shown that you understand their positions as well as they do and have demonstrated good judgment (you agree with them on some important matters and have even been persuaded by something they said).
This is more time consuming and difficult, but it stops people in their tracks. You not only beat your opponents to the punch, minimizing their counterargument “wiggle room,” but a magical conversion may even occur. If you can listen to them, their complaints, their arguments against you, you might even be able to turn your opposition into your biggest supporters! Even if that is a stretch, if you come to at least understand their side, you’ll be able to empathize better and more effectively communicate.

You must struggle with your own beliefs if you are to make any progress in understanding the possibilities and limitations of computers in the intellectual area. To do this adequately you must formalize your beliefs and then criticize them severely, arguing one side against the other, until you have a fair idea of the strengths and weakness of both sides.
– Richard Hamming, Artificial Intelligence
This is in clear opposition to some common and poor strategies that might be reverted to when discussing a touchy subject:
- Straw man – Giving the impression of refuting an opponent’s argument, while actually refuting an argument that was not advanced by that opponent.
- Ad Hominem – Attacking your opponent’s character or personal traits in an attempt to undermine their argument.
- Slippery slope – Asserting that if we allow A to happen, then Z will eventually happen too, therefore A should not happen.
Be on high alert for these types of arguments. Becoming aware of them is the first step to countering them. Also, be aware of filter bubbles or echo chambers, especially today where algorithms drive so much of what we do, see, and hear.
Vitally, for any belief, we must know what disconfirming evidence would change our minds. If you don’t know this clearly and upfront, you don’t grasp the problem as well as you should.
Again, these are high standards, but if put in use, it will save time, headaches, arguments, frustrations, and misunderstandings.
Tangent: Paul Graham on How to Disagree
“…The disagreement hierarchy – name-calling, ad hominem responding to tone, contradiction, counter-argument, refutation.
The most convincing form of disagreement is refutation. It’s also the rarest because it’s the most work. Indeed, the disagreement hierarchy forms a kind of pyramid, in the sense that the higher you go the fewer instances you find. You probably have to quote them and then refute what you think is mistaken. The most powerful form of disagreement is to refute someone’s central point.
A truly effective refutation would look like: the author’s main point seems to be x. As he says…But this is wrong for the following reasons…
The most obvious advantage of classifying the forms of disagreement is that it will help people to evaluate what they read and see through intellectually dishonest arguments. This may help writers too in avoiding unintentional intellectual dishonesty…”
Plain English
Charlie Munger has an appropriately high bar for what it takes to hold an opinion:
“I have what I call an iron prescription that helps me keep sane when I naturally drift toward preferring one ideology over another. And that is I say “I’m not entitled to have an opinion on this subject unless I can state the arguments against my position better than the people do who are supporting it. I think that only when I reach that stage am I qualified to speak.” Now you can say that’s too much of an iron discipline. It’s not too much of an iron discipline. It’s not even that hard to do.”
While not that hard to do, it can be uncomfortable as this means opening yourself up to opinions and points of view, which might starkly contradict your own. However, if we don’t take the time to know all sides, we can easily develop blind spots and unwarranted biases. This mindset allows us to avoid forming rigid conclusions on subjects that we don’t know enough about, partially mitigating The Ignorance Paradox.
A massively important positive unintended consequence of this mindset is that it makes it easier to destroy your own ideas – a vital skill we should all practice. Many are afraid to change their minds because of the innate desire to appear consistent, but we should reserve the right to change our minds at any time. As economist John Maynard Keynes said, “When the facts change, I change my mind. What do you do, sir?” When framed in this way, the absurdity of blind consistency is exposed.
Filter Bubbles
A scenario where a website algorithm selectively guesses what information a user would like to see based on information about the user (such as location, past click behavior, and search history) and, as a result, users become separated from information that disagrees with their viewpoints, effectively isolating them in their own cultural or ideological bubbles.
Two Types of Wisdom
Knowing what you know and knowing what you don’t know. It is just as important to be able to put your finger on what you don’t understand as to put your finger on what you do understand. If you know what you don’t understand, someday you will understand it. If you cover it up with misunderstanding, you are blind forever and will never understand. Only the wise man can say, “This I don’t understand.”
The Dangers of the First-Conclusion and Sunk-Cost Biases
Part of the reason I’ve been a little more successful than most people is I’m good at destroying my own best-loved ideas. I knew early in life that that would be a useful knack and I’ve honed it all these years, so I’m pleased when I can destroy an idea that I’ve worked very hard on over a long period of time. And most people aren’t.
– Charlie Munger, Unplugged
People have bad ideas for several reasons. One reason is that they tend to go with their first idea. You’d think people would spend a couple days thinking through different ideas before spending years on them. They don’t. Part of the problem is that big projects tend to grow out of small ones. So, the biggest cause of big ideas is the still life effect: you come up with a random idea, plunge into it, and then at each point (a day, a week, a month) feel you’ve put so much time into it that this must be the idea. How do we fix that? I don’t think we should discard plunging. Plunging into a good idea is a good thing. The solution is at the other end: to realize that having invested time in something doesn’t make it good.
– Paul Graham, Why Smart People Have Bad Ideas
Technical Description
In order to hold a well-informed opinion, it takes more work than most people are willing to put in. However, this process can serve as our compass to guide us to understand ourselves better, our views, where we stand, and where we might be wrong. This is a tedious process, but the payoffs can be great.
Quotes
There is nothing wrong with changing a plan when the situation has changed.
– Seneca
Faced with information that contradicts what they believe, human beings tend to respond in one of two ways. Some will assimilate the information, changing it so they can ignore the new knowledge and hold on to their former beliefs; and others will accept the validity of the new information. Instead of changing the meaning of the new data to fit their old concept of reality, they adjust their perception of reality to accommodate the information and then they put it to use. Psychologists advise us that the more important the old concept of reality is to a person – the more important it is to his sense of self-esteem and sense of inner worth – the more tenaciously he will hold on to the old concept and the more insistently he will assimilate, ignore or reject new evidence that conflicts with his old and familiar concept of the world. This behavior is particularly common among very bright people because they can so easily develop and articulate self-persuasive logic to justify the conclusions they want to keep.
– Charles Ellis, Winning the Loser’s Game
A new scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making them see the light, but rather because its opponents eventually die, and a new generation grows up that is familiar with it. Science advances one funeral at a time.
Beliefs are hypotheses to be tested, not treasures to be guarded.
– Philip Tetlock, Superforecasting
Strong opinions, weakly held.
Tell me what you know. Tell me what you don’t know. Only then can you tell me what you think. Always keep these three things separate.
– Colin Powell, Psst: Some Hope for Spycraft
Part of the reason I’ve been a little more successful than most people is I’m good at destroying my own best-loved ideas. I knew early in life that that would be a useful knack and I’ve honed it all these years, so I’m pleased when I can destroy an idea that I’ve worked very hard on over a long period of time. And most people aren’t.
The first principle is that you must not fool yourself – and you are the easiest person to fool.
– Richard Feynman, Cargo Cult Science
The test of a first-rate intelligence is the ability to hold two opposed ideas in mind at the same time and still retain the ability to function.
The success of the ‘Origin’ may, I think, be attributed in large part to my having long before written two condensed sketches, and to my having finally abstracted a much larger manuscript, which was itself an abstract. By this means I was enabled to select the more striking facts and conclusions. I had, also, during many years followed a golden rule, namely, that whenever a published fact, a new observation or thought came across me, which was opposed to my general results, to make a memorandum of it without fail and at once; for I had found by experience that such facts and thoughts were far more apt to escape from the memory than favourable ones. Owing to this habit, very few objections were raised against my views which I had not at least noticed and attempted to answer.
– Charles Darwin, Autobiography
There is another trait of great people I must talk about – and it took me a long time to realize it. Great people can tolerate ambiguity, they can both believe and disbelieve at the same time. You must be able to believe your organization and field of research is the best there is, but also there is much room for improvement! You can sort of see why this is a necessary trait. If you believe too much you will not likely see the chances for significant improvements, you will see enough to be filled with doubts and only go for the 2%, 5%, and 10% improvements. I have not the faintest idea of how to teach the tolerance of ambiguity, both belief and disbelief at the same time, but great people do it all the time.
– Richard Hamming, You Get What You Measure
Beware of the power of wishful thinking on your part – you would like it to be true, so you assume it is true!
– Richard Hamming, Computer Aided Instruction
Argue with idiots, and you become an idiot.
– Paul Graham, What You Can’t Say
There’s a trend in our country that is unhealthy. We argue before we understand. That is not a smart thing to do. It sets a terrible example for young people. When there are complicated and contentious issues, honorable people will disagree about what to do. That’s fine. Intelligent people should be able to reach a common understanding about what the problem is before we start screaming about what the solution is. This doesn’t happen anymore. Everything is a shouting match.
– Herbert Meyer, Globalization, Modernity, Western Civ, Islam, and the Rise of the Global Middle Class
Man is not a rational animal, he is a rationalizing animal.
– Richard Feynman, Quantum Mechanics
It is amazing what people can justify to themselves by changing their reasoning.
So convenient a thing it is to be a “reasonable” creature, since it enables one to find or make a reason for everything one has a mind to do.
– Benjamin Franklin, Autobiography
Charlie Munger contributed a great quote to my recent book, from Demosthenes: “Nothing is easier than self-deceit. For what each man wishes, that he also believes to be true.” In other words, there’s a powerful tendency to believe that which could make one rich if it were true.
– Howard Marks, How Quickly They Forget
The purpose of thinking is to let your thoughts die instead of you.
People are cognitive misers and stop thinking the minute they’re satisfied with an answer. The most difficult thing in business is first getting yourself to thinking and then getting others to thinking.
– Harvey Firestone, Men and Rubber
Apply logic to help avoid fooling yourself. Charlie will not accept anything I say just because I say it, although most of the world will.
– Warren Buffett, Poor Charlie’s Almanack
If you can doubt at points where other people feel no impulse to doubt, then you are making progress.
– Chang-Tsai, Why Don’t We Learn From History?
An ignorant mind is precisely not a spotless, empty vessel, but one that’s filled with the clutter of irrelevant or misleading life experiences, theories, facts, intuitions, strategies, algorithms, heuristics, metaphors, and hunches that regrettably have the look and feel of useful and accurate knowledge. This clutter is an unfortunate by-product of one of our greatest strengths as a species. We are unbridled pattern recognizers and profligate theorizers. Often, our theories are good enough to get us through the day, or at least to an age when we can procreate. But our genius for creative storytelling, combined with our inability to detect our own ignorance, can sometimes lead to situations that are embarrassing, unfortunate, or downright dangerous—especially in a technologically advanced, complex democratic society that occasionally invests mistaken popular beliefs with immense destructive power (See: crisis, financial; war, Iraq). As the humorist Josh Billings once put it, “It ain’t what you don’t know that gets you into trouble. It’s what you know for sure that just ain’t so.” (Ironically, one thing many people “know” about this quote is that it was first uttered by Mark Twain or Will Rogers—which just ain’t so.)
– David Dunning, We Are All Confident Idiots
In regard to the philosophers, if they be true philosophers, i.e., lovers of truth, they should not be irritated that the earth moves. Rather, if they realize that they have held a false belief, they should thank those have shown them the truth; and if their opinion stands firm that the earth doesn’t move, they will have reason to boast than be angered.
– Galileo
Interconnected Ideas
Recommended Books & Resources








